Scientific Temper

Biotechnology

GM and genome-edited crops: Bt cotton, GM mustard, edited rice and the rules

Builds on: From rDNA to gene editing (recombinant DNA, SDN-1, 2 and 3) and Reading the genome (RNA interference).

In a nutshell

Crops are engineered to resist pests or herbicides, survive drought or salt, yield more, carry more nutrients, keep longer, or even make medicines. In India, Bt cotton remains the only GM crop grown commercially; GM mustard was cleared by the regulator in 2022 but is held up in the Supreme Court; and two genome-edited rice varieties were released in 2025 under the lighter rules for edits that add no foreign DNA. Behind each case lie questions of safety, ecology, farmers' costs and who owns seeds.

  1. The technology: transgenic (GM) or edited without foreign DNA.
  2. The cases: Bt cotton, HTBt cotton, GM mustard, genome-edited rice.
  3. The rules: GEAC and the 1989 Rules; the Cartagena Protocol; patents and farmers' rights.

Trait wantedTechnique chosenRegulatory route

Almost all the cotton grown in India is Bt cotton, a GM crop introduced in 2002. Yet in many fields its protection against the pink bollworm has broken down, farmers are illegally planting an unapproved herbicide-tolerant version, and GM mustard, a food crop approved by the regulator, has been stuck in court since 2022. Meanwhile, genome-edited rice went to farmers in 2025 without the same hurdles. What separates these cases?

This topic applies the tools of the last topic to agriculture. Three things matter: which technique suits which purpose; what crops have been engineered for; and the few Indian cases, Bt cotton, GM mustard and genome-edited rice, that are debated in policy and the press.

GM or genome-edited?

As the previous topic showed, a crop carrying a gene from another species is transgenic; today such crops are made by recombinant DNA technology and are called GM crops. A crop whose own genes have been changed by SDN-1 or SDN-2 editing carries no foreign DNA and is called genome-edited. The distinction is not only technical: in India it decides the regulatory route. Any transgenic crop, such as Bt cotton, Bt brinjal, HTBt cotton, GM mustard or Golden Rice, goes through the full GM approval process; SDN-1 and SDN-2 edited crops without foreign DNA have been exempt since 2022. With today's technology, transgenic traits are still introduced mainly by rDNA, not by editing.

What crops are engineered for

PurposeHow it worksExample
Resistance to pests (biotic stress)The plant makes its own insecticidal proteinBt cotton (India); Bt brinjal (approved in Bangladesh in 2013; under moratorium in India since 2010)
Herbicide toleranceThe crop survives a weedkiller that kills the weeds around itGlyphosate-tolerant soybean and maize abroad; HTBt cotton (not approved in India)
Tolerance of drought, salinity, floods (abiotic stress)Genes affecting water use or salt handling are changedPusa DST Rice 1, genome-edited for drought and salinity tolerance (India, 2025)
Higher yieldHybrids made possible; or genes controlling grain number changedGM mustard DMH-11; DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala), genome-edited rice (India, 2025)
Better nutrition (biofortification)Added genes for a nutrientGolden Rice (beta-carotene); "Protato", a higher-protein potato developed in research at NIPGR, Delhi
Longer shelf lifeSlowing the softening of fruitFlavr Savr tomato (US, 1994), the first GM food sold, which used an antisense gene (see Reading the genome)
Edible vaccinesThe plant makes a pathogen's antigen, so eating it could train the immune systemBananas with a hepatitis B antigen, rice with a cholera antigen: research only, none approved
Molecular farming ("pharming")Plants, plant cells or animals made into factories for medicinesAn enzyme for Gaucher disease made in carrot cells (approved in the US in 2012); antibodies made in tobacco plants
EnvironmentPlants or microbes engineered to make biodegradable materials or break down pollutantsPlants making bioplastics such as PHB (research); microbes that digest oil or plastics (bioremediation)

Two cautions. Not every improved variety is engineered: the flood-tolerant "scuba rice" Swarna-Sub1, released in India in 2009, carries a gene from a traditional Odisha rice variety moved by conventional, marker-assisted breeding, and most of India's biofortified crop varieties, such as high-iron pearl millet and high-zinc rice and wheat, are conventionally bred. And edible vaccines remain an idea: dosing is hard to control when the vaccine is a fruit.

Bt cotton

Bollworms, caterpillars that bore into cotton bolls, were the main pest of Indian cotton, controlled with heavy pesticide spraying. The soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) makes crystal proteins (Cry proteins) that are toxic to certain insects: when a caterpillar eats them, they bind to receptors in its gut and rupture it. Mammals, birds and most other insects lack these receptors, so the protein is specific. Inserting the cry gene into cotton makes every part of the plant toxic to bollworms.

India approved Bt cotton in 2002 (Bollgard, with one Cry protein), followed by Bollgard II (two Cry proteins) in 2006. Within a decade more than 90 per cent of India's cotton area was under Bt hybrids; spraying against bollworms fell and yields rose sharply in the 2000s.

The gains have since eroded:

  • Resistance. The pink bollworm evolved resistance, first to Bollgard by about 2008–09 in Gujarat, then to Bollgard II by the mid-2010s. Resistance was speeded by the failure to plant refuges (strips of non-Bt cotton where susceptible insects survive and dilute resistant genes) and by long-duration hybrids that kept food available to the pest late into the season. Responses include pheromone traps and mating disruption, short-duration varieties and, in future, RNA interference sprays that silence an essential pest gene (see Reading the genome).
  • Secondary pests not controlled by Bt, such as the whitefly, which devastated cotton in Punjab in 2015.
  • Costs and seed. Bt cotton is sold as hybrids, which farmers must buy each season, because seed saved from a hybrid does not breed true and yields less. The government has regulated Bt cotton seed prices and the trait fee paid to the technology owner since 2015–16.

Herbicide tolerance, HTBt cotton and glyphosate

Weeding by hand is expensive and labour is scarce, so farmers turn to weedkillers. Most effective herbicides, such as glyphosate, are non-selective: they kill the crop too. A herbicide-tolerant (HT) crop carries a gene that lets it survive the herbicide, so the field can be sprayed and only the weeds die. HTBt cotton combines this with Bt. It has not been approved in India, but seed is sold and planted illegally.

Concerns about HT crops include heavy herbicide use and the evolution of herbicide-resistant weeds; residues in soil, water and food; harm to field margins that support pollinators and other insects; and the loss of weeding work, much of it done by women. Glyphosate itself is contested: the WHO's cancer agency (IARC) classified it in 2015 as "probably carcinogenic to humans", while several other regulators have disagreed. In October 2022 India restricted its use to licensed pest control operators.

GM mustard: DMH-11

India imports more than half of the edible oil it consumes, and raising oilseed yields is the aim of the National Mission on Edible Oils – Oilseeds approved in 2024. Mustard is a major oilseed, but its yields are low. Hybrids, the first-generation offspring of two different parent lines, usually yield more than either parent (hybrid vigour). Making hybrids requires stopping a plant from pollinating itself, which is hard in mustard because each flower carries both male and female parts and largely self-pollinates. Conventional methods to make one parent male-sterile exist, but have been difficult to use widely in mustard.

Scientists at the Centre for Genetic Manipulation of Crop Plants, Delhi University, used two genes from a soil bacterium:

  • Barnase, inserted into the variety Varuna, destroys pollen production, making it male-sterile: it can only be pollinated by another plant, so it serves as the female parent.
  • Barstar, inserted into the variety Early Heera-2, blocks barnase. When Early Heera-2 pollinates Varuna, the hybrid inherits barstar and is fertile again, so farmers' crops set seed normally.
  • A third gene, bar, which gives tolerance to the herbicide glufosinate, was added to both parents as a marker to identify successfully modified plants.

The hybrid, DMH-11 (Dhara Mustard Hybrid-11), was reported in trials to yield about 28 per cent more than Varuna. Its developers also see barnase–barstar as a platform for producing other mustard hybrids.

In October 2022 the GEAC approved its environmental release. The decision was challenged. In July 2024 a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court gave a split verdict: one judge held the approval flawed, citing among other things the absence of health experts in the decision; the other upheld it. The case was referred to a larger bench, and both judges asked the Centre to frame a national policy on GM crops. The arguments:

  • For: higher yields to cut edible oil imports; a home-grown, publicly developed technology; a platform for new hybrids; years of biosafety testing.
  • Against: the bar gene makes DMH-11 herbicide-tolerant in effect, which could encourage glufosinate spraying; possible harm to honeybees and other pollinators that visit mustard; India is a centre of mustard diversity, so genes could spread to other varieties; questions about whether long-term health and yield comparisons were adequate; and the claim that non-GM hybrids could achieve similar gains.

Genome-edited rice

In May 2025 ICAR released two rice varieties made by SDN-1 editing, the first genome-edited crop varieties released in India:

  • DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala), developed at the Indian Institute of Rice Research, Hyderabad, from the popular variety Samba Mahsuri, with an edit that increases the number of grains per panicle. It yields more and matures about three weeks earlier, saving water.
  • Pusa DST Rice 1, developed at the Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi, from the variety MTU 1010, with an edit to a gene (DST) that improves tolerance of drought and salinity.

Because they contain no foreign DNA, they did not need GEAC approval under the 2022 exemption, and they can be multiplied and supplied to farmers like conventionally bred varieties.

Engineering the plant is not the only biological route into a field. Living organisms are also applied to the crop and the soil: nitrogen-fixing and phosphorus-releasing biofertilisers, mycorrhizal fungi, and biopesticides such as Bt sprays and Trichoderma. These change what is available to the plant rather than what the plant is, and they are taken up in Environment and industry.

How India regulates GM organisms

GM organisms are governed by the Rules, 1989 (for the manufacture, use, import, export and storage of hazardous micro-organisms and genetically engineered organisms or cells) framed under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. They set up six committees:

CommitteeUnderRole
Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee (RDAC)Department of BiotechnologyReviews developments and recommends safety rules
Institutional Biosafety Committee (IBSC)Each research institutionOversees GM research on site
Review Committee on Genetic Manipulation (RCGM)Department of BiotechnologyApproves research and contained field trials
Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee (GEAC)Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate ChangeApex body: approves large-scale trials and environmental (commercial) release
State Biotechnology Coordination Committee (SBCC)State governmentMonitors and enforces in the state
District Level Committee (DLC)District administrationMonitors at the district level

GM foods also need approval from the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. Internationally, India is a party to the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety (adopted 2000, in force 2003) under the Convention on Biological Diversity, which requires a country's informed agreement before living modified organisms are exported to it for release into its environment.

Who owns the seed?

Farmers have saved, shared and resown seed for thousands of years, which is how crop varieties survived. Companies that spend years developing a GM or improved variety want a return. India balances these interests through two laws:

  • The Patents Act (Section 3(j)) does not allow patents on plants, seeds or varieties (see From rDNA to gene editing).
  • The Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001 lets breeders register new varieties and earn from them, but protects farmers' right to save, use, sow, resow, exchange, share and sell their farm produce, including seed of a protected variety, as long as they do not sell it as branded seed under the variety's name. When PepsiCo sued Gujarat farmers in 2019 for growing a potato variety it had registered, the case drew wide criticism and was withdrawn.

One technology has been kept out altogether. Genetic use restriction technology (GURT), popularly "terminator seeds", would make a crop's seeds sterile, forcing farmers to buy new seed every season. The Convention on Biological Diversity recommended a moratorium on its field testing and commercial use in 2000, no terminator crop has ever been commercialised, and India's PPVFR Act bars the registration of varieties containing such technology. The need to rebuy Bt cotton seed comes from its being a hybrid, not from any terminator gene.

Ownership of a variety is only part of the question. The plants and microbes themselves, and the knowledge of how to use them, belong somewhere too. The Convention on Biological Diversity established that countries have sovereign rights over the biological resources within their borders, and its Nagoya Protocol (2010, in force 2014) sets out how a user must obtain prior informed consent for access to a genetic resource or to associated traditional knowledge, and agree how the benefits will be shared. India's Biological Diversity Act, 2002 gives this effect through the National Biodiversity Authority, State Biodiversity Boards and local Biodiversity Management Committees, which maintain People's Biodiversity Registers.

Biopiracy is the name for taking such a resource or knowledge without that consent and benefit sharing, and typically patenting it elsewhere. The familiar Indian examples are the patents granted abroad on the wound-healing use of turmeric and on a fungicidal use of neem, both later revoked, and the basmati case in which a US patent's claims were substantially narrowed. These episodes led India to build the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library, which puts documented knowledge from Indian systems of medicine into a form patent examiners abroad can search, so that it counts as prior art. One live dispute concerns digital sequence information: when a resource is reduced to a published genome sequence that anyone can download, it is contested whether the benefit-sharing obligation still attaches, and that argument runs through both the biodiversity negotiations and the pandemic-preparedness talks (see Identity markers).

India's key cases at a glance

CropTechniqueTraitStatus in India
Bt cottonrDNA (transgenic)Bollworm resistanceApproved 2002; only GM crop grown commercially
HTBt cottonrDNA (transgenic)Bollworm resistance + herbicide toleranceNot approved; grown illegally
Bt brinjalrDNA (transgenic)Fruit and shoot borer resistanceMoratorium since 2010 (grown in Bangladesh)
GM mustard DMH-11rDNA (transgenic): barnase, barstar, barHybrid seed for higher yieldGEAC approval 2022; split Supreme Court verdict 2024; larger bench pending
DRR Dhan 100, Pusa DST Rice 1Genome editing (SDN-1)Yield, earliness; drought and salt toleranceReleased May 2025; exempt from GM rules

Recent developments

India releases its first two genome-edited rice varieties

The Union Agriculture Minister released two genome-edited rice varieties developed by ICAR on 4 May 2025 in New Delhi. DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala), from the Indian Institute of Rice Research at Hyderabad, was bred from Samba Mahsuri by editing a gene that limits grain number; it matures about 15 to 20 days earlier, at around 130 days, with a reported yield gain of roughly 19 to 25 per cent, and the shorter duration saves about three irrigations. Pusa DST Rice 1, from the Indian Agricultural Research Institute at New Delhi, was bred from MTU 1010 by editing the DST gene and is aimed at tolerance of salinity and alkalinity. Both used SDN-1 editing, in which the cell's own repair of a cut introduces the change and no foreign gene remains.

Why it matters: Here the regulatory distinction drawn in this chapter has a concrete consequence. Because SDN-1 and SDN-2 edited plants carrying no foreign DNA were exempted from the GM rules in 2022, these varieties could be released through the ordinary varietal channel, while GM mustard and Bt brinjal remain stalled. The claim to be first should also be stated carefully: India is the first country to release genome-edited varieties of rice, not the first to release a genome-edited crop. And a released variety is not yet a planted one; seed multiplication decides when farmers actually sow it.

Remember: DRR Dhan 100 (Kamala), from Samba Mahsuri - earlier maturity, more grains per panicle, three irrigations saved. Pusa DST Rice 1, from MTU 1010 - salinity and alkalinity tolerance. Both are SDN-1 edits carrying no foreign gene, which is why they fall outside the GM approval route. Released 4 May 2025.

Source: Prasar Bharati News Services, May 2025

Last-month notes
  • Bt: Bacillus thuringiensis Cry proteins rupture the gut of specific insects. Bt cotton 2002 (Bollgard), Bollgard II 2006; over 90% of cotton area.
  • Pink bollworm resistance: Bollgard by ~2008–09, Bollgard II by mid-2010s; refuges not planted. Whitefly in Punjab, 2015.
  • Glyphosate: IARC "probably carcinogenic" (2015); India restricted use to pest control operators (October 2022). HTBt cotton not approved.
  • GM mustard DMH-11 (Delhi University, CGMCP): Varuna (barnase, male-sterile) × Early Heera-2 (barstar, restorer); bar gene: glufosinate tolerance. GEAC approval Oct 2022; SC split verdict July 2024.
  • Genome-edited rice (May 2025): DRR Dhan 100 Kamala (IIRR; from Samba Mahsuri) and Pusa DST Rice 1 (IARI; from MTU 1010).
  • Swarna-Sub1 (scuba rice): flood-tolerant, conventional marker-assisted breeding, not GM.
  • Rules 1989 under EP Act 1986; committees RDAC, IBSC, RCGM (DBT), GEAC (MoEFCC), SBCC, DLC. Cartagena Protocol (2000; in force 2003).
  • PPVFR Act 2001: farmers may save, sow, share and sell seed but not as branded seed. GURT ("terminator"): CBD moratorium 2000; never commercialised.
  • Access and benefit sharing: Nagoya Protocol (2010, in force 2014) under the CBD; India's Biological Diversity Act 2002, with the NBA, State Biodiversity Boards and Biodiversity Management Committees (People's Biodiversity Registers).
  • Biopiracy cases: turmeric and neem patents revoked, basmati claims narrowed; Traditional Knowledge Digital Library created as searchable prior art. Digital sequence information is the live dispute.
  • First GM food: Flavr Savr tomato (1994). Plant-made medicine: enzyme from carrot cells (2012).

Statements to watch for

  • Bt cotton is the only GM crop commercially cultivated in India; genome-edited rice is not legally a GM crop.
  • Barnase causes male sterility; barstar restores fertility.
  • The Bt protein is specific to certain insects; it is not a broad-spectrum poison.
  • GEAC is under the environment ministry, not the agriculture ministry.
  • The terminator moratorium came under the Convention on Biological Diversity; the Cartagena Protocol governs the movement of living modified organisms across borders.
  • Edible vaccines are still experimental.
  • The Nagoya Protocol governs access to genetic resources and the sharing of benefits; the Cartagena Protocol governs transboundary movement of living modified organisms. Both sit under the Convention on Biological Diversity.
  • The turmeric and neem patents were revoked and the basmati claims narrowed; the TKDL exists to make such knowledge searchable as prior art.

Revise and apply

Activities to check your understanding, not new content. Answer first, then press Check or Show answers. Multiple-choice questions are original, in the UPSC style, not past UPSC questions. A printable workbook with all activities is on the theme page.

Complete the mind map

Type the missing words, then check.

GM and genome-edited crops
Bt cotton
Bacterium: Bacillus
Pest that evolved resistance: pink
GM mustard
Makes the female parent male-sterile:
Restores fertility:
Gives herbicide tolerance: gene
Genome-edited rice (2025)
From Samba Mahsuri: DRR Dhan 100 or
Drought and salt tolerant: Pusa Rice 1
Rules
Apex approval body:
Treaty on movement of LMOs: Protocol
Fill in the blanks
  1. Strips of non-Bt cotton planted to slow the evolution of resistance are called .
  2. In 2022 India restricted the use of the herbicide to licensed pest control operators.
  3. The first GM food sold, a tomato with longer shelf life, was the tomato.
  4. Farmers' rights to save and share seed are protected by the PPVFR Act of .
  5. Seeds engineered to be sterile, nicknamed terminator seeds, use genetic use technology.
GM rules or exempt?

Which of these needs approval under India's GM rules, and which is exempt?

  1. Bt brinjal
  2. Rice with a gene knocked out by SDN-1
  3. GM mustard DMH-11
  4. HTBt cotton
  5. Rice with a two-letter change made by SDN-2, no foreign DNA
  6. Golden Rice
True or false? Correct the false ones
  1. GM mustard DMH-11 is designed mainly to improve the nutritional value of mustard oil.
  2. Swarna-Sub1 (scuba rice) is a transgenic variety.
  3. The GEAC functions under the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.
  4. Under the PPVFR Act, a farmer may not sell seed of a protected variety as branded seed.
  5. Terminator seed technology has been commercialised in the United States.
Decode the headline

"Supreme Court delivers split verdict on GM mustard." (a) What problem was GM mustard meant to solve? (b) Give two arguments raised against its release.

UPSC-style question 1

With reference to GM mustard DMH-11, consider the following statements:

  1. The barnase gene makes one parent line male-sterile.
  2. The barstar gene restores fertility in the hybrid.
  3. It contains a gene that confers tolerance to a herbicide.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

UPSC-style question 2

Which of the following crops is/are exempt from India's rules for genetically engineered organisms?

  1. A rice variety in which a gene has been knocked out by SDN-1 editing, with no foreign DNA
  2. A cotton variety carrying a bacterial gene for herbicide tolerance
  3. A brinjal variety carrying a Bt gene

Select the correct answer:

Write in about 50 words

Bt cotton's success in India has been followed by serious problems. Discuss. Answer in about 100 words.

0 words

The next question If we can edit the genes of a crop, can we also correct a faulty gene in a patient? How does gene therapy work, and what has it achieved for diseases such as sickle cell disease?