Scientific Temper

Nuclear technology

Nuclear reactor technologies

Builds on: Fission and nuclear fuels (fissile and fertile fuels, moderators, enrichment).

In a nutshell

A nuclear power plant works like a coal plant with a different source of heat: controlled fission heats a coolant, the heat makes steam, and the steam turns a turbine and generator. Reactor types differ in three choices: the fuel (natural uranium, enriched uranium or plutonium), the speed of the neutrons (slow or fast) and the coolant (light water, heavy water or liquid metal).

Fission heatCoolantSteamTurbine and generator

India runs heavy water reactors at Rawatbhata, light water reactors at Kudankulam, boiling water reactors at Tarapur and a sodium-cooled breeder at Kalpakkam. Why does one country need so many designs? Because each is a different answer to the same three choices: fuel, neutron speed and coolant.

How does a nuclear reactor generate electricity?

Fission produces heat, but heat alone is not electricity. A nuclear power plant does two jobs:

  1. it extracts energy from the nucleus through a controlled fission chain reaction; and
  2. it transfers that heat to a system that drives a turbine and generator.

The second job is the same as in a coal-based thermal power plant. In a coal plant the heat comes from combustion; in a nuclear plant it comes from fission.

  1. Nuclear fuel undergoes fission in the reactor core
  2. The core heats up
  3. Coolant carries the heat away
  4. The heat makes steam, which drives a turbine
  5. The turbine turns a generator: electricity
From fission to electricity. Only the first step is nuclear.
ComponentWhat it does
Nuclear fuelUndergoes fission
Reactor coreHolds the fuel and the controlled reaction
ModeratorSlows neutrons (in thermal, that is slow-neutron, reactors)
Control rodsAbsorb neutrons to regulate or shut down the reaction
CoolantRemoves heat from the core
Steam generatorPasses heat to a separate steam circuit, in some designs
ContainmentA thick structure around the reactor that helps prevent radioactive releases

Not every reactor uses all of these, or uses them in the same way. A fast reactor, for example, has no moderator.

Why are there different reactor technologies?

Each reactor design is a particular combination of three choices:

  • Fuel: natural uranium, enriched uranium, plutonium-based fuel, or another material.
  • Neutron speed: slow or fast.
  • Coolant: light water, heavy water, liquid metal, or another substance.

These choices are linked. Natural uranium has very little U-235, so a reactor that uses it must waste very few neutrons. Heavy water achieves this, which is one reason India chose the pressurised heavy water reactor. Light water reactors use ordinary water, which absorbs more neutrons, and make up for it by enriching the uranium. The choice of reactor is therefore tied to the fuel a country has, and to whether it can enrich.

Pressurised heavy water reactor (PHWR)

Natural uranium fuel, with heavy water as moderator and coolant: the mainstay of India's indigenous programme.

  • Natural uranium is the fuel.
  • Heavy water acts as both moderator and coolant.
  • The coolant is kept under pressure so that it does not boil in the core.
  • Hot heavy water passes its heat to ordinary water in a separate steam generator, and that steam drives the turbine.

The main advantage is that no enrichment is needed. India's PHWRs operate at Rawatbhata (Rajasthan), Narora, Kakrapar, Kaiga, Kalpakkam and Tarapur. The indigenous design has been scaled up from 220 MWe to 700 MWe units. Canada's CANDU reactors are of the same family.

Light water reactors: PWR and BWR

Enriched uranium, with ordinary water as both moderator and coolant. They differ in where the steam is made.

Light water means ordinary water (H2O). Most of the world's power reactors are light water reactors, of two kinds.

PWR: two separate water circuits Reactor water kept liquid by high pressure Steam generator steam Turbine Coolant from the core never reaches the turbine. BWR: one circuit Reactor boils here steam Turbine condensed water returns Steam from the core goes straight to the turbine.
The one difference that matters between a PWR and a BWR: where the steam is made. A PHWR uses the PWR arrangement, but with heavy water.
  • Pressurised water reactor (PWR): the water passing through the core is kept under high pressure so that it does not boil. It passes its heat through a steam generator to a separate, secondary water circuit, which boils and drives the turbine. The reactor coolant and the turbine steam stay in separate circuits. Kudankulam's Russian-designed VVER reactors are PWRs.
  • Boiling water reactor (BWR): the water boils inside the reactor vessel itself, and the steam goes directly to the turbine before being condensed and returned. Tarapur units 1 and 2, India's oldest reactors, are BWRs.
FeaturePWRBWR
FuelEnriched uraniumEnriched uranium
Moderator and coolantOrdinary waterOrdinary water
Boiling inside the coreNoYes
Steam circuitSeparate secondary circuitSteam made directly in the reactor
Indian exampleKudankulam (VVER)Tarapur 1 and 2

Fast breeder reactors

Fast neutrons, no moderator, plutonium fuel and liquid sodium coolant; able to make more fissile fuel than they burn.

The reactors above all use slow neutrons. A fast breeder reactor uses fast neutrons and does not slow them down, so it has no moderator.

Why build one? U-238 is fertile: it absorbs neutrons and becomes fissile Pu-239. A fast breeder runs on plutonium-containing fuel, and the fission of plutonium by fast neutrons releases enough neutrons both to keep the chain reaction going and to convert fertile material placed around the core into new fissile fuel. Under suitable conditions it produces more fissile material than it consumes. This is breeding.

The core is compact and produces heat very densely, so the coolant must remove heat very efficiently without slowing the neutrons. Water would slow them, so fast reactors commonly use liquid sodium. Sodium reacts vigorously with air and water, which calls for specialised engineering and safety systems.

FeatureFast breeder reactor
NeutronsFast
ModeratorNone
FuelCommonly uranium–plutonium mixed oxide (MOX)
CoolantCommonly liquid sodium
PurposeGenerate energy and breed fissile fuel
Indian examplePFBR, Kalpakkam (500 MWe)

Two qualifications. Not every fast reactor is a breeder: that depends on whether it actually makes more fissile material than it uses. And fast reactors still need control rods and shutdown systems, even without a moderator.

The four reactor types compared

FeaturePHWRPWRBWRFBR
Common fuelNatural uraniumEnriched uraniumEnriched uraniumUranium–plutonium MOX
NeutronsSlowSlowSlowFast
ModeratorHeavy waterOrdinary waterOrdinary waterNone
CoolantHeavy waterOrdinary waterOrdinary waterCommonly sodium
SteamSeparate steam generatorSeparate steam generatorMade in the reactorThrough intermediate heat-transfer circuits
Indian exampleKakrapar, RawatbhataKudankulamTarapur 1 and 2PFBR, Kalpakkam

These are representative configurations, not rules for every design.

Nuclear reactor safety and decay heat

Every reactor must meet three safety requirements:

  1. control the chain reaction;
  2. remove heat from the core; and
  3. prevent the release of radioactive material.

The second requirement does not end when the reactor is shut down. Even after the chain reaction stops, the radioactive fission products in the fuel keep decaying and producing heat. This is decay heat. If cooling is lost, the fuel can overheat and be damaged, which is what happened at Fukushima in 2011 after the tsunami knocked out power to the cooling systems. This is why reactors need emergency cooling, backup power and containment.

Consolidation

Reactors differ mainly in fuel, neutron speed and coolant. PHWRs matter most for India because they run on natural uranium. PWRs and BWRs both use enriched uranium and ordinary water but differ in how steam is made. Fast breeders add a new possibility: making fissile fuel from fertile material while generating electricity, which gives India a path from limited uranium towards thorium.

Recent developments

No dated updates for this topic yet.

Last-month notes
TypeFuelModeratorCoolantIndia
PHWRNatural UHeavy waterHeavy waterMost reactors; 700 MWe units
PWR (VVER)Enriched ULight waterLight water, pressurisedKudankulam
BWREnriched ULight waterLight water, boils in coreTarapur 1 and 2
FBRU–Pu MOXNoneLiquid sodiumPFBR, Kalpakkam

Statements to watch for

  • PWR: no boiling in the core; BWR: boiling in the core.
  • A fast reactor has no moderator but does have control rods; not every fast reactor is a breeder.
  • A shut-down reactor still needs cooling (decay heat).

Revise and apply

Activities to check your understanding, not new content. Answer first, then press Check or Show answers. Multiple-choice questions are original, in the UPSC style, not past UPSC questions. A printable workbook with all activities is on the theme page.

Complete the mind map

Type the missing words, then check.

Reactor types
PHWR
Fuel: uranium
Moderator and coolant:
PWR (VVER)
Fuel: uranium
Water kept under
India:
BWR
Water in the core
India:
Fast breeder
Neutrons:
Coolant: ; no moderator
India: , Kalpakkam
Safety
Heat after shutdown: heat
Failure at (2011)
Fill in the blanks
  1. A nuclear plant works like a thermal plant except that its heat comes from .
  2. In a PWR the reactor coolant and the turbine steam are kept in circuits.
  3. Fast reactors use liquid sodium because water would the neutrons.
  4. Even after shutdown, a reactor must be cooled because of heat.
  5. India's first nuclear power station, at , began operating in 1969.
Odd one out

Pick the odd one out in each set.

True or false? Correct the false ones
  1. A shut-down reactor needs no further cooling.
  2. In a PWR the coolant boils inside the core.
  3. Kudankulam's reactors are Russian-designed VVERs.
  4. Every fast reactor is a breeder.
Decode the headline

"Fukushima: tsunami knocks out power to cooling pumps; fuel damaged though reactors had shut down." (a) Why did shut-down reactors overheat? (b) Which safety requirement failed? (c) What protects the public if fuel is damaged?

UPSC-style question 1

With reference to nuclear reactors, consider the following statements:

  1. In a boiling water reactor, steam produced in the reactor vessel drives the turbine directly.
  2. In a pressurised water reactor, the water in the core is kept under pressure so that it does not boil.
  3. The reactors at Kudankulam are boiling water reactors.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

UPSC-style question 2

Fast breeder reactors use liquid sodium rather than water as coolant mainly because:

UPSC-style question 3

Why must a nuclear reactor continue to be cooled even after its chain reaction has been stopped?

Write in about 50 words

Why did India choose PHWRs for the first stage of its nuclear programme?

0 words
Write in about 50 words

What lesson about reactor safety did Fukushima teach?

0 words

The next question A fast breeder can make more fuel than it burns. Why does that matter so much for a country with little uranium and a great deal of thorium?